What to do when there is a herd of elephants in your neighbouring unit?

Contents

In a recent case one unlucky unit dweller has described the sound travelling from his upstairs neighbours as being subjected to a “booming sound”, “like a herd of elephants coming down at you” and “living underneath the thunderdome in my own home”. You may ask what could lead to such a ruckus?

As commonly occurs in home renovations, the unit above had installed floating floors. The installation of the floors had reportedly greatly increased the noise to the unit below.

Whilst your first plan of attack in dealing with any issues that arise in your strata should be to have a friendly chat with your neighbours to try and work out a solution, if this doesn’t work you do have options. The Strata Schemes Management Act 2015 restricts your neighbours from using their lot in a way that will cause nuisance to other lot owners. Your particular strata scheme may also have by-laws that deal with the situation.

If a neighbourly chat doesn’t resolve the issue you can apply to the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal for orders to assist. Whilst the forum is intended to be user friendly, as an applicant you must still prove to the Tribunal that there is a real problem requiring intervention.

This is where our unlucky unit dweller went astray. His application relied on only his uncorroborated personal account of the noise. The Tribunal found that he should have substantiated his claim by providing additional expert evidence about the noise, either from a builder or an acoustic engineer.

Whilst there is a cost in engaging these experts to provide an opinion, it may be money well spent if you don’t want to be living under the thunderdome!

Lorri Field

Lorri is a director of PDC Law. Lorri combines excellent technical expertise with a common-sense approach to best represent her clients. She is one of few Accredited Specialists in Commercial Litigation in the Illawarra and Shoalhaven. This accreditation is testament to Lorri’s expert knowledge and skill in dealing with commercial disputes. In 2019 Lorri was awarded Regional Lawyer of the Year by Women Lawyers Achievement Awards.

Recent articles

Browse some recent articles from the PDC Law blog.

What the Cardaci Case Means for You: A Warning for Trustees

Introduction A recent court decision in Cardaci v Filippo Primo Cardaci as executor of the estate of Marco Antonio Cardaci [No 5] [2023] WASCA 158 has important lessons for anyone involved with a family trust, whether you are a trustee, a beneficiary, or considering setting up a trust. The High Court’s dismissal of the trustee’s appeal…

Victoria Absolon

Legal Update: NSW Strata Law Reforms from 1 July 2025

Introduction On the 1 July 2025, major reforms to the NSW strata laws came into effect. The reforms aim to protect owners corporations, improve the accountability of strata management services, ensure the maintenance of common property by the owners corporation and make living in strata schemes easier for residents.   Summary of Key Changes 1.…

Sarah Hilton
Call (02) 4288 0150 phone